Share Purchase vs Asset Sale: Choosing a Business Sale Structure in QLD

When people talk about buying or selling a business, they usually talk about price. Structure tends to come up later, often when an accountant raises it. Yet the way a deal is put together decides what actually changes hands, which liabilities travel with it, how much duty is paid, and how easily the business keeps trading the day after settlement.

There are two main ways to do it. Here is what each involves, and the questions that usually point towards one or the other.

What is the difference between asset purchase and share purchase?

In an asset sale, the buyer buys selected parts of the business, such as goodwill, equipment, stock and the business name, and the seller keeps the legal entity. In a share purchase, the buyer buys the company that owns the business, so everything inside it, including its history and liabilities, comes along.

A simple way to put it: an asset sale moves the contents of the house; a share sale moves the house itself.

Can every business be sold through a share sale?

No. A share sale is only possible when the business is owned by a company. If you trade as a sole trader or a partnership, there are no shares to sell, so the sale will be an asset sale. Businesses run through a trust have their own variations, such as selling units in a unit trust.

This is the step many small business owners miss.

So the first question is not "which is better?" but "who actually owns the business?" It is worth confirming this early, because some owners have restructured over the years and the trading entity is not always the one on the sign out front.

How an asset sale works

The seller's entity sells the assets the parties agree on, and the buyer usually sets up a fresh entity to receive them. Each asset has to be transferred in its own way: the premises lease is assigned with the landlord's consent, contracts are novated or assigned, licences are transferred or reissued, and employees are offered new employment.

Why buyers often prefer it

  • You choose what you are buying and leave behind what you are not.

  • Debts, tax history and past disputes generally stay with the seller's entity.

  • It is easier to see exactly what you have paid for.

Why sellers sometimes find it harder

  • The seller is left with an entity that still needs winding up or tidying.

  • Each transfer needs its own paperwork, consent or approval.

  • Contracts and licences that cannot be transferred may need to be renegotiated.

If the business trades from leased premises, the lease is often the hinge of the whole deal. Assigning a lease usually needs the landlord's consent, and for retail shop leases, the disclosure process under the Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 has its own timing. Our commercial property team often works on the lease side of a sale alongside the main contract, because a delay there can hold up settlement.

How a share sale works

The owners of the company sell their shares to the buyer. The company itself does not change. It keeps its contracts, its employees, its lease, its licences and its bank accounts, so from the outside, very little appears to happen.

Why sellers often prefer it

  • A cleaner exit, with the whole entity passing to the buyer.

  • Fewer individual transfers and consents.

  • Possible tax advantages, depending on how the shares are held.

Why buyers approach it carefully

  • Past liabilities stay inside the company, including ones nobody has found yet.

  • Due diligence needs to go deeper and cover the company's whole history.

  • Protection relies heavily on the contract itself.

That last point is where the share purchase agreement does most of its work. It usually contains warranties from the seller about the company's accounts, tax, employees, disputes and compliance, along with indemnities that make the seller responsible if certain problems surface after settlement. A buyer also tends to ask for part of the price to be held back or paid later as a cushion.

It is also worth checking contracts and leases for change-of-control clauses. Some leases and supplier agreements treat a change in who owns the company as if it were an assignment, so consent may still be needed even in a share sale. Finding those clauses is usually part of the due diligence our business and commercial lawyers carry out before a buyer commits.

Share sale vs asset sale tax: What tends to differ

Tax often drives the decision, and it is the area where advice from your accountant matters most. A few broad points tend to come up.

  • Queensland transfer duty. Queensland charges transfer duty on Queensland business assets, including goodwill, plant, stock and business names, so an asset sale is usually dutiable, and the buyer pays it. A transfer of shares in a private company generally does not attract transfer duty in Queensland. The exception is landholder duty, which can apply where the company holds Queensland land above the threshold set by the Duties Act 2001. Where land is part of the deal either way, the property and conveyancing work usually runs alongside the business contract rather than after it.

  • GST. An asset sale may be GST-free as the supply of a going concern if the conditions are met, including that the business is carried on up to the day of sale and both parties agree in writing. A share sale is treated differently for GST purposes.

  • Capital gains and concessions. Sellers may have access to the small business CGT concessions in either structure, but eligibility can turn on who owns what and for how long. Buyers in an asset sale generally get a fresh cost base for the assets, while a buyer of shares inherits the company's existing tax position.

None of this lends itself to a rule of thumb. The same business can produce quite different results for buyer and seller depending on the structure, which is often why the two sides start out preferring different options and negotiate from there.

Employees and accrued entitlements

Staff are a real consideration for small businesses. In a share sale, employees stay employed by the same company, so their service and entitlements continue without interruption. In an asset sale, the buyer usually offers employment to the staff it wants to keep, and the contract needs to deal with who bears accrued leave and other entitlements. That allocation is commonly reflected as an adjustment to the price at settlement.

Questions that help point to a structure

Whether you are buying or selling, these tend to settle the asset vs share sale question faster than any general rule:

  • Who owns the business: a company, a trust, a partnership or a sole trader?

  • Is there anything in the company the buyer would rather not take on?

  • How much does the business rely on its lease, key contracts or licences staying in place?

  • Does the company or trust hold Queensland land?

  • What does each side's accountant say about duty, GST and CGT?

  • How many staff are there, and what entitlements have built up?

  • How much due diligence can realistically be done before the deadline?

Getting the structure right early

The structure shapes every document that follows, from the heads of agreement through to the final contract and the settlement statement. Changing course partway through can be done, but it usually costs time and goodwill on both sides. We are happy to work alongside your accountant from the start, so the legal and tax pieces are pulling in the same direction.

Whether you are planning an exit or looking at your first acquisition, it helps to talk it through before anything is signed. You are welcome to get in touch to arrange a consultation.

Disclaimer: This article is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice. If you require legal advice in relation to your personal circumstances, you must formally engage our firm or another firm to provide legal advice in relation to your matter. Bradley & Bray lawyers take no responsibility for any use of the information provided in this article.



If you would like to discuss this or any other matter, call us today on 07 5441-1400 or email info@bradleybray.com.au.

Previous
Previous

Celebrating 40 Years of Debbie Davis at Bradley Bray!

Next
Next

Making Sense of Fit-Out Agreements & Make-Good Clauses in QLD Commercial Leases